Tag Archives: Total Debt Servicing Ratio

Effects of TDSR so far

The impact of the Total Debt Servicing Ratio (TDSR) became quickly apparent when it was introduced in June 2013, with private home sales dropping 73.3 percent to 482 units in July 2013 from 1,806 units in June 2013, said media reports.

Analysts noted suburban homes were most affected. Data compiled by Knight Frank Singapore indicated new home sales in the suburbs fell 63 percent in H2 2013 from the first half of the year.

Aimed at ensuring financial prudence among borrowers, the TDSR specifies that the total monthly payments’ of a borrower, including car and home loans and even credit card debts, should not exceed 60 percent of the borrower’s income.

Alice Tan, Knight Frank’s Director of Consultancy and Research, said, “The TDSR basically impacts on mortgage loan eligibility and affordability of private homes and the mass market segment typically caters to upgraders and middle-income home buyers.”

Tan noted these buyers might have decided to forego their purchases after their loan requests have been rejected.

Meanwhile, the effect of TDSR on prices became apparent only on the latter part of the year. Notably, the Urban Redevelopment Authority (URA)’s residential property price index slipped 0.9 percent in Q4 2013, marking its first decline in almost two years.

Home prices dipped again in Q1 2014 by 1.3 percent – its biggest drop since Q2 2009 – when prices plunged by 4.7 percent.

The TDSR also affected the private residential resale market. CBRE figures showed that sales volume in the secondary market fell 50 percent in H1 2014 from H1 2013.

With this, some developers have offered discounts to boost sales. However, other developers are unlikely to do so for some projects as they have “limited room to adjust their prices due to the high land prices they have committed to, earlier on,” said Tan.

Moving forward, developers may build smaller units, which will enable them to offer affordable prices while keeping their profit margins.

Price cuts at prime central private homes too

THE sale is on for private residential projects in the prime central region, following price cuts for city fringe and suburban projects which helped developers move more unsold units.

Palms @ Sixth Avenue, a strata landed semi-detached project, is offering to absorb the 7 per cent additional buyer’s stamp duty which existing Singaporean home owners have to pay for a second residential property.

With this, prices will go from $5.3 million to $4.9 million for a 4,510-sq-ft unit, and from $7 million to $6.5 million for a 5,834-sq-ft one. The discounted prices translate to a per square foot range of $1,086 to $1,114.

The project will receive its temporary occupation permit (TOP) in the first quarter of 2015.

Meanwhile, Hallmark Residences along Ewe Boon Road in Bukit Timah is offering a discount of more than 10 per cent for several of its units.

A 969-sq-ft two-bedder, for instance, will cost $1.9 million, down from $2.1 million. Three-bedders will cost $2.8 million instead of $3.1 million, and four-bedders, $3.5 million instead of $4 million. An actual show unit will be open for a one-day-only viewing tomorrow, an agent told The Business Times.

R’ST Research director Ong Kah Seng said “it was only a matter of time” before core central region (CCR) projects started to cut prices. “They have been left substantially unsold for quite a long time, and generally buyers’ interest for CCR projects has been very weak. Well-located projects like these have hefty price tags, and previously, there wasn’t the total debt servicing ratio (TDSR) framework limiting large loans. Some buyers like to overstretch their loan limits by buying costly homes with high leasing demand and hence, investment potential. But they can no longer do so after the TDSR.” The TDSR, which requires financial institutions (FIs) to take into consideration borrowers’ other debt obligations when granting property loans, is aimed at strengthening credit underwriting practices by FIs and encouraging financial prudence among borrowers.

Developers of CCR projects feel compelled to cut prices as the TOP dates of their developments loom closer, because empty units paint a discouraging picture of the projects and buyers may turn sceptical about their investment potential, Mr Ong said.

Two other condo projects in the city fringes are also re-launching units at lower prices.

8M Residences along Margate Road in the East Coast is offering an 8 per cent direct discount on its one to three-bedroom units.

For instance, an 893-sq-ft three-bedder will now cost $1.6 million, from $1.8 million. Per-square-foot prices range from $1,832 to $2,015, a breather from the median $2,100 psf at which its units transacted until April 2014. Buyers may opt to take a 10 per cent “rental guarantee” package by purchasing at the current price and getting a 5 per cent cash-back from the developer annually for two years – even while renting out the unit and receiving actual rental income.

One Eighties Residences is giving a 13 per cent discount on its two-bedroom units and penthouses, which will now start at $890,000 and at $1.4 million respectively.

Derrick Poh, marketing and communications manager at Santa United, the developer, told BT of the Joo Chiat development: “We’ve received enquiries, but those didn’t turn into sales. Buyers are keeping a lookout and shopping around, expecting developers to reduce prices based on the current market outlook.”

In any case, the lull in the June holiday period is driving developers and agents to take any measures they can to move sales, “probably now more so with World Cup fever distracting buyers away from home purchases”, Mr Ong said.

Source: STProperty