Tag Archives: Mah Bow Tan

Bring back rental flats in big way

May I suggest that the Government consider restoring the HDB rental system in a big way. During the early days of this nation, this was how many Singaporeans were adequately housed when they were resettled from kampungs. One-, two- and three-room Housing and Development Board (HDB) flats were rented out to those who could not buy.

Why is it that these smaller flats were subsequently either perceived by the HDB as lacking a demand, or was it a matter of policy? What is wrong with living in a small flat even on rental if it means affordability and having more disposable income for other uses?

The Japanese people are known to live in “rabbit hutches”, as a former Prime Minister of theirs said. But still they can make their small living environment nice and liveable.

In any case, HDB flats on purchase have a 99-year lease. Owners are really lessees only, according to the HDB agreement.

If the monthly rental of a three-room HDB flat is only half the amount needed for purchase – say S$500 instead of a S$1,000 monthly instalment – one can save S$500 in cash or in CPF which ensures a bigger nest egg for retirement. One can also use the savings to invest in low-risk types of investment like international government bonds with a return starting from 4 per cent annually.

Under the current situation, much of the CPF savings of a HDB lessee can be used up in paying for a new HDB flat whose value may start depreciating 50 years into the lease – which, incidentally, would be at the point of one’s retirement age.

And one’s HDB flat cannot be easily liquidated as cash for use because one will always need housing. Indeed, the Government has proposed that an eligible lessee sell it back to the HDB for a monthly payment that can be used for living expenditures in his/her old age.

The Government should seriously consider restoring the rental system for HDB flats. This is on top of the urgent need to quickly build more flats to house new families.

Letter from Chia Hern Keng

Source : Today – 17 May 2011

Good news for new home buyers

First-time home buyers will welcome the call to raise the income ceiling to qualify for new HDB flats, property analysts said yesterday, a move which will also benefit the sandwiched class.

National Development Minister Mah Bow Tan has hinted that the income ceiling for new build-to-order (BTO) flats could be raised to S$10,000 – from the current S$8,000 – after the General Election.

Analysts welcome the plans to raise the income ceiling.

Calling the move an overdue one, Mr Mohamed Ismail, chief executive of property company PropNex, said the public has sent a very strong signal.

“I think the sandwiched class has indicated: ‘Hey, the ceiling at S$8,000 we are neither here nor there’ and especially now … the younger generations are getting married much later,” he said.

Currently, those earning above S$10,000 a month can only buy flats under the Design, Build and Sell Scheme (DBSS) and Executive Condominiums (ECs). They can also buy from the resale market or purchase private apartments.

The key executive officer of ERA Realty Network, Mr Eugene Lim, said: “The gripe with this class is that they can’t buy the most affordable housing in Singapore and they are forced to buy at a higher price which puts a strain on them financially. I think this group of people will be very happy with this new policy.”

Analysts say the higher income ceiling for new flats is not likely to have a significant impact on the overall property market – given that the sandwiched class is only a small part of the property market. But some say the resale HDB market could still be marginally hit.

Mr Lim said: “We’ll probably see some of the buyers who currently buy from the resale market moving to BTO flats because there’s always a preference for new over old. “When you buy a resale flat, you’re buying old flats but at higher prices. Now you can buy new flats at subsidised prices.”

First-time BTO flat buyers will probably make adjustments to their plans. Those buying BTO flats have to factor in the three-year construction period.

Some analysts say they do not see any immediate impact on property prices in the HDB resale market, saying that there is an eight-year gap before any of the BTO flats become eligible for resale.

This year, the HDB is looking to build around 22,000 flats under the BTO scheme – the largest supply in recent years.

The review of the income ceiling is likely to be conducted after the polls and will be completed within six months, National Development Minister Mr Mah said.

Source : Today – 9 May 2011