Tag Archives: Hong Kong Property

En bloc debate, HK style

WHEN land is scarce, your right to live in your home ends when your neighbours sell theirs.

This logic applies not just to Singapore – which defied expectations by recently producing its first collective sale offer since the recession took hold – but also to Hong Kong, which is now deep in debate over proposed changes to its compulsory property sale rules.

On the surface, the operative concept in both cities is the same: Urban renewal is expensive, and private capital speeds up the process. The government lends a hand by allowing an estate to be sold even if the sale does not get the unanimous approval of all the owners.

But Hong Kong and Singapore differ in the weight each accords to minority owners. Singapore requires an 80 per cent consent for a sale of a property at least 10 years old, and a 90 per cent approval for a development less than 10 years old.

Meanwhile, Hong Kong has maintained a 90 per cent threshold since the 1990s, with a tribunal giving the final go-ahead Continue reading