Tag Archives: HDB Rental Flats

More rental flats needed, say MPs

Members of Parliament (MPs) said there is a need to raise the supply of rental flats significantly, to match demand.

They said despite a shorter waiting time, there are still segments of the population who need rental flats quickly.

Their comments come a day after Minister for National Development Khaw Boon Wan said there was a need to ramp up the supply of these flats by “tens of thousands”.

MPs said based on their Meet-The-People sessions, demand for rental flats comes from low-income families and households facing difficult times.

MP for Tanjong Pagar Group Representation Constituency (GRC) Chia Shi-Lu said: “Giving a conservative estimate of five cases a week, 20 cases per month, and about 200 cases a year — and we spread that out among the 87 zones in Singapore — we’re looking at 15 to 16,000 applicants”.

Rental flats are meant to cater to poor and needy families who have no housing options.

Today, there are some 45,000 units in Singapore.

With rent as low as S$26 a month, the demand for such units is always high.

Even after tightening rules to prevent abuse of the system, the wait for one of these units can be relatively long.

HDB said the queue for rental flats is now about 1,700 applicants, down from 4,600 in 2009.

Waiting time has also been reduced from an average 21 months in 2008, to about eight months currently.

Even so, new cases continue to pour in every month.

In March this year, former National Development Minister Mah Bow Tan disclosed that HDB received 190 applications for rental flats each month last year.

On concerns from existing home owners that their property value may drop if rental flats were built in their neighbourhood, Dr Chia said more education is needed.

He said he has yet to see evidence of property values being affected by their proximity to rental flats, and added that other factors such as location and availability of amenities are likely to affect prices more.

MP for Holland-Bukit Timah GRC Liang Eng Hwa said rental blocks should be spread out across the island and integrated into neighbourhoods.

With the recent increase in Build-To-Order flats, and the proposal to have more rental units, Mr Khaw said the industry cannot cope with the demand for nearly 40,000 flats a year.

The industry currently has the capacity to build half that number, the Singapore Contractors Association said.

It faces many challenges in trying to ramp up supply so quickly – including a tight labour situation and rising costs due to rising foreign worker levies, higher dormitory and transportation costs.

In addition, there is the issue of sustainability.

Singapore Contractors Association 2nd vice-president Kenneth Loo said: “For the industry, it wouldn’t be good if (in) one year, we double the capacity, and the following year, we have to halve it”.

Channel NewsAsia understands HDB has been speaking to construction companies since last year about the possibility of ramping up the supply of new flats.

There are currently an estimated 20 regular HDB contractors.

Source : Channel NewsAsia – 30 May 2011

Rental flats supply set to increase

Minister for National Development Khaw Boon Wan said there is a shortage of rental flats in Singapore, and there is a need to ramp up supply by “ten of thousands”.

However, Mr Khaw said it will take some time to make up this shortfall, as the construction industry is unable to cope with the sudden surge in demand.

Mr Khaw spoke about the need to ramp up the supply of rental flats, during a youth forum at the Woodlands Community Club.

“Single mothers, divorcees (may) suddenly have no flat (or) no money to buy (one), so they are counting on rental (flats),” Mr Khaw said.

“Then there are all kinds of HDB rules that prevent them from renting. The rules are not frivolous.

“The problem HDB faces is that they are just short of rental flats. It’s quite clear in my mind — we need to ramp up the building of rental flats as quickly as we can. Not just by a few thousands; actually we need to (increase) by tens of thousands. And the earlier the better.”

This comes two days after the HDB announced the supply of new BTO flats will be increased this year from 22,000 to 25,000 units.

Mr Khaw said the HDB needs to build “almost similar numbers” of rental flats, but said there are challenges.

While Mr Khaw is keen to ramp up the supply of new flats quickly, he admitted the construction industry cannot cope with this sudden surge in demand.

The industry is used to building some 15,000 units a year.

As such, Mr Khaw said it will take some time to meet demand.

Mr Khaw added he needs to study the capacity of the construction industry to understand how fast flats can be built.

Meanwhile, Mr Khaw was asked at the forum, about the large presence of foreigners in Singapore.

Some in the audience said they felt threatened when it came to competition for jobs.

Mr Khaw acknowledged that too many foreigners were allowed in, the last few years, and there was a need to calibrate the numbers.

But he noted the relationship between economic growth and foreign labour, and said by reducing their numbers, Singaporeans are accepting there will be trade-offs.

Mr Khaw said: “We thought (taking foreigners in) was important to bring wages to people’s pockets, so that we can grow as fast as we can… (and) catch up with other countries.

“But now, we get the message that ‘we don’t want so much growth, that we are prepared to accept slower growth’.

“It actually affects the youth immediately, because when you slow down growth, it means that job opportunities also come down (and) starting pay also comes down”.

Other issues touched on at the forum included alternative pathways for youths who want to pursue the arts, and global competition.

Source : Channel NewsAsia – 29 May 2011